The Influence of the Anti-Vaccine Movement

This week, Americans began receiving COVID -19 vaccines, with the hope that by the middle of next year a pandemic that has claimed the l...


This week, Americans began receiving COVID-19 vaccines, with the hope that by the middle of next year a pandemic that has claimed the lives of more than three hunded thousand Americans will be brought under control. Misinformation about the virus has been a staple of both the Trump Administration’s messaging and much of the junk science found on the Internet. Now, that misinformation will intersect with an American public that is already somewhat skeptical about vaccines, potentially imperilling the effort to get a sufficient number of Americans vaccinated. (The Times reported on Wednesday that many of the people spreading false claims about voter fraud have switched their messaging to the dangers of vaccines.)

To try to understand why anti-vaccine sentiment is so prevalent in the United States, I recently spoke by phone with Dr. Peter Hotez, a professor of pediatrics and molecular virology at Baylor College of Medicine, and the co-director of the Texas Children’s Center for Vaccine Development. In March, he will publish a book called “Preventing the Next Pandemic: Vaccine Diplomacy in a Time of Anti-Science.” During our conversation, which has been edited for length and clarity, we discussed the historical reasons for vaccine skepticism among many Black Americans, how doctors can speak the truth without appearing political, and how the fight over vaccines became so similar to the fight over every political issue in America.

When we’re talking about why people are resistant to vaccines, how much is that a question for doctors to answer, and how much is it a question for social scientists or other people to answer?

Not all vaccines are created equal, and each vaccine has its own set of issues around hesitancy. In general, when we’re talking about vaccines, we’re usually talking about vaccines for kids. And the three vaccines that are primarily targeted are the M.M.R. vaccine for measles, mumps, rubella; the H.P.V. vaccine; and the flu vaccine. What’s happened in the United States is that, historically, there has been a rise and fall of anti-vaccine sentiment ever since colonial times, with smallpox vaccinations. But the modern piece of this really started to accelerate in the early two-thousands, after a paper by Andrew Wakefield and his colleague was published in The Lancet, falsely claiming that the measles, mumps, and rubella vaccine had the ability to cause autism. Back then they called it pervasive developmental disorder.

That whole thing was debunked by a journalist for the Times of London, a guy named Brian Deer, who wrote a series of articles, first in the Times and then in the British Medical Journal, the BMJ. And that Lancet paper ultimately got retracted, but not until 2010. So that period enabled an anti-vaccine movement to flourish in the U.K., and then it took off in the United States. And in the United States it acquired its own flavor, in that, starting around 2014 or 2015, it got linked to the political right under this fake banner that they called “health freedom, medical freedom.” It started in Southern California, but it really got amplified here in Texas, and we started to see a steep increase in parents who were opting their kids out of getting vaccinated. And it coincided with the formation of these political-action committees, Texans for Vaccine Choice, Oklahomans for Vaccine and Health Choice. And they started getting money from organizations that traditionally would support the Tea Party and other far-right-wing causes. So they gave money, and power, and strength, and political alliances. And then it really took off with Robert F. Kennedy and his anti-vaccine group, Children’s Health Defense, which became one of the first major national anti-vaccine groups.

One of the things that seems interesting about anti-vaccine sentiment is that it is a far-right thing in certain ways, but it also crosses certain ideological lines. If you look at some of the places where opposition to vaccinations for children is highest, it’s places like Santa Monica and Marin County, which I don’t think of as part of a right wing—

Yeah, or in Seattle. So there’s a Pacific Northwest flavor to that, which is linked more to the health-and-wellness industry. The point is the anti-vaccine lobby doesn’t all speak with one voice. That’s absolutely true. That’s why I sometimes call it a confederacy more than one single organization. And that gets to the sources of funding as well, which we don’t really understand. Some of it’s coming from the health-and-wellness industry selling fake supplements and autism cures, while a lot of it is getting money from far-right-wing political causes. But it’s gotten very powerful now, to the point it really dominates the Internet.

You alluded to anti-vaccination sentiment rising and falling since colonial times. Is there a through line that can help us understand why sentiment rises or falls, or why distinct populations see sentiment within them rise or fall? Or is it just things like this Lancet paper, about which it would be hard to come up with some sort of historical explanation?

It comes from different causes. So for instance, because I have a daughter with autism, I wrote this book “Vaccines Did Not Cause Rachel’s Autism.” In the book, I report on doing a PubMed search, where you type in key words like autism and vaccines, and you do see one paper comes out of 1976, and a guy who was looking at smallpox vaccination and wondering, “Could there be a link to autism?” And then nothing. And then all of a sudden the Wakefield paper comes, and this thing just blows up after that.

So clearly it’s that Wakefield paper that was the trigger. But what gave it momentum, though, I think, was the political alliances and links. And again, under this banner of health freedom, we’re seeing that stuff expand this year. Because while it was very focussed on vaccines —which, by the way, started bringing people like Rush Limbaugh and Alex Jones into it—in 2020 it glommed on to the protest against masks and social distancing. So what was an anti-vaccine movement then morphed into a full-on anti-science movement.

And then the other thing that happened this year, which I hadn’t seen before, was it went outside the U.S. and North America. It went to western Europe. So you started seeing these protests in Paris and Berlin and London, again using that same health-freedom language. And we have anti-mask and anti-vaccine rallies. There are other versions of anti-vaccine activities globally, but this one had that American spin to it that I hadn’t seen before.

According to polls, if you ask people about their skepticism of COVID-19 vaccines, you see that Black and Latino adults are more skeptical. At the same time, you see Republicans as much more skeptical than Democrats. The explanation for the former has traditionally been that the medical community has a very checkered history with nonwhite populations in this country and elsewhere. Is that how you see it?

It’s the thing you mentioned. I think the other is the absence of African-American health-care providers, especially physicians, especially male physicians. We really are doing a very bad job training African-American physicians. But the third piece that no one really talks about, which I think is quite important, if you start looking into it, is that these anti-vaccine groups staged anti-vaccine rallies in Harlem in 2019. So I think there was specific targeting of African-American groups. The movement targets specific groups. It went after the Somali-immigrant community in Minnesota in 2017, and it basically generated a measles epidemic. Then they went after the Orthodox Jewish community in New York in 2018, 2019. And they use very inflammatory, exploitative language, comparing vaccines to the Holocaust.

Most people in the United States in 2020 don’t have an experience with measles, but COVID-19 is something that everyone has had some experience with. What are the unique challenges or unique advantages of getting Americans to buy into a COVID-19 vaccine? How is it different?

Well, I think that you now have a couple of challenges. One, you have the anti-vaccine lobby, the anti-vaccine groups. One of the things that they’ve been doing the last few years is specifically targeting new vaccines. So they really went after, for instance, the H.P.V. vaccine for cervical cancer and other cancers. And now they’re going after the COVID-19 vaccine and coming up with all sorts of outrageous assertions. Then on top of that, you have the fact that while the White House and Operation Warp Speed did a good job in terms of the scientific rigor and integrity of the clinical trials, they never had a communication plan. And that left a big vacuum. So I think those things really combined to work against us in a big way. Because intuitively you would think that people would be clamoring for a vaccine, and it’s surprising how many aren’t.

What can medical professionals do to ameliorate some of these things you’re talking about? And to what degree is this now a political matter, and medical professionals can’t do much?

Well, first of all, I think the federal government needs to do two things, one of which I think they’re starting, and the other, which so far they’ve resisted, and most people have resisted. The first thing they need to do is implement a communications plan. And I know it’s going to start with a series of public-service announcements. I don’t think that’s going to be adequate. I think because there are going to be issues on a regular basis, they’re going to need government scientists out there on a frequent basis, sort of like what Cuomo did in New York in March and April, but for vaccines. And I’m prepared to do that as much as possible. But I think having government scientists, people whose faces get familiar, is going to make a big difference. That’s No. 1. No. 2, which nobody seems to have the appetite for, is you’ve got to take down the confederacy, the anti-vaccine empire. You’ve got to take the content off social media, off Facebook. I mean, Amazon right now is the single largest promoter of fake anti-vaccine books. That’s got to stop.

Source link

COMMENTS

Name

Africa,728,Americas,3908,Art & Culture,14226,Arts,6334,Arts & Design,1525,Asia,3115,Automobile,415,Baseball,502,Basketball,401,Books,3726,Business,5167,Celebrity,2593,Cricket,605,Crime,121,Cryptocurrency,1389,Dance,587,Defense,796,Diplomatic Relations,2451,Economy,1009,Editorial,260,Education,1118,Elections,291,Energy & Environment,2989,Entertainment,22086,Environment,3469,Europe,4064,Faith & Religion,205,Family & Life,775,Fashion & Style,3086,Finance,18979,Food & Drink,3576,Football,1027,Games,74,Gossip,10245,Health & Fitness,3917,Health Care,871,Hockey,181,Home & Garden,881,Humour,950,Latin America,49,Lifestyle,16229,Media,490,Middle East,1399,Movies,1581,Music,2486,Opinion,2732,Other,11226,Other Sports,4868,Political News,11236,Political Protests,2280,Politics,17282,Real Estate,1687,Relationship,63,Retail,3070,Science,2473,Science & Tech,9487,Soccer,159,Space & Cosmos,276,Sports,11401,Technology,3269,Tennis,505,Theater,1562,Transportation,275,Travel,2438,TV,3529,US Sports,1434,Video News,3531,War & Conflict,1026,Weird News,954,World,15566,
ltr
item
Newsrust: The Influence of the Anti-Vaccine Movement
The Influence of the Anti-Vaccine Movement
https://media.newyorker.com/photos/5fda7f290e2c11a8253ca387/16:9/w_1280,c_limit/Chotiner-Vaccines.jpg
Newsrust
https://www.newsrust.com/2020/12/the-influence-of-anti-vaccine-movement.html
https://www.newsrust.com/
https://www.newsrust.com/
https://www.newsrust.com/2020/12/the-influence-of-anti-vaccine-movement.html
true
732247599994189300
UTF-8
Loaded All Posts Not found any posts VIEW ALL Readmore Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All RECOMMENDED FOR YOU LABEL ARCHIVE SEARCH ALL POSTS Not found any post match with your request Back Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS PREMIUM CONTENT IS LOCKED STEP 1: Share to a social network STEP 2: Click the link on your social network Copy All Code Select All Code All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy Table of Content